Friday, February 6, 2009

a review of Eclipse

Eclipse by Richard North Patterson

Oil and it's production around the world is certainly a very timely subject. The lengths that corporations and governments and individuals will go to for that black gold, in a volatile world, with huge amount of money at stake, is at the heart of the story of Eclipse.

Damon Pierce is a very successful lawyer whose marriage is over, he and his wife seeming to have just drifted apart. And at the same time, he seems to be drifting away from his work as a lawyer, having lost a sense of purpose in his work. When into this rather soulless life comes a cry for help from a woman he once, and perhaps still loves, he can't help but respond. Marissa e-mails him to say that her husband, Bobby Okari, has been arrested and charged with murder of three oil company workers in his West African country of Luandia and to ask for Damon's help. Her husband, who she met when he was speaking at colleges in the USA years ago, is the leader of a populist movement that is trying to affect chance in his homeland, but branded a terrorist by the corrupt government of Luandia. Her only hope to save Bobby from almost certain execution, she thinks, is to appeal to someone outside the country that can bring to bear some political and diplomatic influence and bring world attention to her husband's plight.

Luandia is a country in chaos, an environmental nightmare, it's people in appalling poverty, led by a madman, General Savior Karama. People that speak up against the government simply disappear, as we find out, to suffer some truly horrible fates. It is into this world, a terribly dangerous world, that Damon flies, driven both by his affection for Marissa but also because of a great admiration for Bobby and a hope that he can somehow help save both Marissa and her husband. The situation seems hopeless and Damon knows that he may well lose his own life in the attempt.

According to what I have read, the story is based in no small part on the actual history of Nigeria and a very disturbing story it is. The book starts off very well and, for example, an early scene of a massacre in a village where Bobby had just spoken, while horrifying, is extreme well written and moving. The description of the destruction of the delta and the destruction of the lifestyle of the tribal people living there is vivid. But sadly, the rest of the book is not as compelling. Once Bobby is arrested and Damon starts his investigation, the book seems to lapse into a series of clandestine meetings and a lot of rather pompous, preachy speeches with stilted dialogue. Also none of the characters are ever really fully developed enough to really make the reader care about them. As I have said before, for me, the appeal of fiction ultimately comes down to, in no small part, compelling characters.

The book bills itself as a thriller, a piece of fictional entertainment, even if it is based on true events and is trying to present a certain message. I don't mind a book with a message nor am I saying that I disagree with the message, but I am saying that I don't want to be hit over the head with it and be well aware that I am being hit over the head with it. If I am, I think the author has failed his primary task, which is to present us with a compelling story and with characters we care about.

A few wonderful, gripping scenes in what I found was ultimately a rather disappointing book.

Available From Amazon

for another opinion, check out...
Presenting Lenore


  1. I was hoping to read a rave review since this is in my TBR pile.

  2. Sorry.:-)
    But if you look at Amazon (which I like to after I write my review) a fair number of people agree with me..but then some loved it too.

  3. It's too bad this one didn't click for you, Caite. I love novels that have timely political issues in them, but like you I don't want to be preached to. Subtlety is the name of the game, no?

  4. In my opinion, that is true. If it is that obvious, what is the author's 'message' then I think to a degree he has already failed as a novelist.

    I am sure there are readers...and authors that would disagree, but first of all, I need to find fiction entertaining. If it the end, I realize that the author has presented me with a point of view, especially one I normally disagree with, and made me see it a little differently and told me a great story as well...well, then they has succeeded.

  5. I don't like preachy fiction either. Strangely, I didn't find this preachy so I was kind of surprised to see that you did.

    I did find the whole "we are all complicit in africa's misery because we use oil" to be kind of annoying - was that what bothered you? Like if we all go back to the dark ages Africa will be better off?

  6. Yes, I would certainly consider that part of the preachy part. Just all so black and white, with no subtlety. As long as you drive a car or heat your home or have electricity in your house, I think you have to make a better argument.

  7. I got the sense though that it was just one point of view (Okari's) and that Patterson showed the complexity of the issue and that there are no easy solutions.

  8. This comment has been removed by the author.

  9. Obviously you liked it more than I see, I never felt that I 'knew' any of the characters well enough to hear it through their 'voice'. I am not sure totally why, but I never felt that I connected to any of the characters very much. I am not sure if I said it before but maybe about half way through I realized that I just didn't care about them...and that is a deadly sign for me in a book.


please speak up, I LOVE TO HEAR FROM YOU!!